Thursday, July 13, 2006

Live from New York ! -- the ASBH Politics and Bioethics conference!

Listen to our podcasts (1 and 2) about the how the 'rumble' in Albany started off with a bang!

Fellow blogger Alison McCook had this to say about the conference:

The Bioethics & Politics conference hosted by the Albany Medical College got off to a bang today, not a whimper. As participants trickled in, networking and finding old friends, another, uninvited group calmly filed in, parked in front of the room, and started shouting at the tops of their lungs.

The protesters, around 30 or so, were from Not Dead Yet, a disability rights group that is against legalized euthanasia and other forms of "medical killing," as they call it. The meeting hall became quickly filled with cries of "nothing about us without us." Members quickly distributed fliers to participants that explained they were upset that conference organizers had gathered people from both sides of the political spectrum, but failed to include advocates of the disabled.

Huh? I’m all about pluralism, but the conference is about politics, and with only a day and a half at our disposal, it makes sense to focus the discussion. However, the director of the AMC’s Alden March Bioethics Institute, Glenn McGee, to his credit, took the microphone and said the organizers had decided to give Not Dead Yet a chance to speak. (Glenn even managed to open with a joke: "As you can see, everything is going according to plan.") Representative Stephen Drake spoke for 10 minutes about how politics is not important to people at the front lines of hot button issues ("We live in a world where partisan lines aren’t that important"), and received as much applause as any pre-planned speaker did the rest of the day. After his speech, he and his colleagues left, and it was all very civil.

The experience clued me in to the fact that bioethicists are, by the nature of their purview, adept at handling heated debates and, hopefully, finding a compromise many people can live with. If only other discussions had such a happy ending as this one.

Tuesday, July 11, 2006

Diagnosing Medical Malpractice -- Curing the Ailment, not just treating the symptoms

Senate Majority leader Bill Frist's answer to runaway health-care spending is to cap jury awards in medical malpractice suits -- for the fifth time in four years, he tried and failed to cap awards at $250,000 during his self-proclaimed "Health Care Week" in May.

But how's this for a novel approach?: Sens. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama also want to save on health care, but rather than capping jury awards, they hope to cut the number of medical malpractice cases by reducing medical errors, as they explain in the New England Journal of Medicine.

Supporting this approach is a recent study out of the Harvard School of Public Health that showed that the legal system does a good job of weeding out claims without merit.




World's First 'test-tube' baby set to give birth; baby conceived the 'old-fashioned' way

On July 25, 1978, Louise Joy Brown, the world's first successful "test-tube" baby was born in Great Britain. Now the world's first test-tube baby is expecting a baby of her own. Brown, 27, is due to give birth in January. She has been married for two years to a security officer, Wesley Mullinder, and their baby was conceived the old-fashioned way."This is a dream come true for both of us," Brown told Britain's The Daily Mail newspaper. The couple live outside of Bristol where Brown is an administrative assistant for a shipping firm. They made headlines in 2004 when they married. The pregnancy is yet another in a long list of headlines surrounding Brown's life that began in such an unusual way.

Access to Abortion as a Human Rights Issue

Women's E-news reports that a Polish woman, Alicja Tysiac, applied for an abortion a few years ago, but her medical grounds were refused. She wound up carrying the pregnancy to term and losing her sight. Now her case awaits judgment by the European Court of Human Rights.

Friday, July 07, 2006

Rudeness ok for docs, says court

At first glance, you might think this was a story from the National Enquirer, but you'd be wrong. Apparently a New Hampshire physician told an obese patient that she was so fat "only black men would want her." The patient sued.

The judge agreed that the remark was uncalled for, but said that the physician had a right to speak bluntly, writing, "It is nonetheless important ... to ensure that physicians and patients are free to discuss matters relating to health without fear of government reprisal, even if such discussions may sometimes be harsh, rude or offensive to the listener."

Sure, sure--docs have free speech rights the same as the rest of us. But it seems neither professional nor kind. . . . which I think are characteristics we'd like to see in our physicians, no? One hopes that some professional organization will have something more to say to the doc in question.

Thursday, July 06, 2006

Johann Hari: Why I support liberal eugenics

Johann Hari of the Independent claims this has nothing to do with the evils of Nazi eugenics; it is entered into by parents and it is motivated by love.

Can anyone say "genetic idolatry"? Aren't we more than the sum of our genes? Or are we mere 'meatbots'?

Shades of "The Dead Zone" -- the rewired brain

Anyone who has watched the USA network's series The Dead Zone will be surprised (or maybe not) to hear that doctors contend that man's brain rewired itself after being in a minimally conscious state for 19 years. According to the Boston Globe, Terry Wallis awoke from a coma-like state 19 years after tumbling over a guardrail in a pickup truck and falling 25 feet into a dry riverbed. Now doctors armed with some of the latest brain-imaging technology think they may know part of the reason why.

Wallis showed few outward signs of consciousness, but his brain was methodically rebuilding the white-matter infrastructure necessary for him to interact with the outside world, researchers reported yesterday in the Journal of Clinical Investigation.

``I believe it's a very, very slow self-healing process of the brain," said Henning Voss, lead author of the study and a physicist at Weill Cornell Medical College's Citigroup Biomedical Imaging Center.

Wallis emerged from a minimally conscious state in 2003 at the age of 39 and uttered his first word since Ronald W. Reagan was in the White House: ``Mom." Since then, the onetime mechanic from Big Flat, Ark., has regained the ability to form sentences and recovered some use of his limbs, though he still can't walk or feed himself.

Using both PETscans (Positron Emission Tomography scans) and an advanced imaging technique called diffusion tensor imaging, the researchers examined Wallis's brain after he regained full consciousness, and found that cells in the relatively undamaged areas had formed new axons, the long nerve fibers that transmit messages between neurons.

``In essence, Terry's brain may have been seeking out new pathways to reestablish functional connections to areas involved in speech and motor control -- to compensate for those lost due to damage," said the study's senior author, Dr. Nicholas Schiff, a neurologist at the Weill Cornell Medical College in New York.

Thursday, June 29, 2006

Bioethics Rumble? Let's Roll!

A recent AJOB blog cites the building anticipation for a potential “bioethics rumble” at the ASBH Summer Conference: Bioethics and Politics: The Future of Bioethics in a Divided Democracy,” to be held July 13-14, 2006 at the Crowne Plaza in Albany, NY. Linda MacDonald Glenn and I will be blogging live from the conference and will report any bloodshed.

We were delighted that WBP’s soon to be published whitepaper was selected to be presented at the conference. Below is the abstract:

Bioethics and Public Policy:A Competitive Analysis of Americans United for Life

How does an established, pro-life advocacy group reshape itself into a self-proclaimed “non-profit, public interest bioethics law firm” using bioethics to drive its political agenda? Bioethics and Public Policy: A Competitive Analysis of Americans United for Life examines the strategies and tactics of one of the most prolific and active conservative organizations that is working to shape bioethics public policy through legislation, pro bono legal counsel, and public opinion. Analysis of Americans United for Life’s programs—such as model state legislation on bioethical issues, whereby they provide everything a state legislator would need to draft, defend, publicize and push through legislation—illustrates how an organization’s ability to focus at a state level to promote a conservative bioethics agenda fits in to the bigger picture of conservative politics. Americans United for Life also has important connections to influential D.C. based conservative think tanks and bioethics centers. It’s a fascinating look at how political influence directly shapes bioethics in the world today.

For more information on the conference: http://politics.bioethics.net/

Wednesday, June 28, 2006

Diagnosing The Right Depression


Seeking help for depression is the first step. But there are different types of depression, which need their own specific treatments. Learn the differences and what you can do to get better.

Such Obscenity!

From guest blogger, Peter J. Cohen, MD, JD, Adjunct Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center and Chair, Physician Health Committee, Medical Society of the District of Columbia:

I breathed a profound sigh of relief when I learned that the Congress had passed legislation increasing penalties for broadcast indecency as I am now assured that my eyes will no longer be assailed by “wardrobe malfunctions.” However, I wonder when our lawmakers will see fit to deal with the far more significant indecencies—nay obscenities—which we observe in our daily newspapers and TV news broadcasts every day. Just a few examples come to mind:

  • Deplorable infant mortality, a disgrace to our nation
  • Our impoverished people who suffer and die every day for lack of even basic health care
  • Our society—far more concerned with the “legality” of immigrants than with their humanity
  • A volunteer army that allows the overwhelming majority of our population to remain completely unaffected by our wars
  • A system of lobbying, campaign financing, and influence peddling that make a mockery out of the democratic process

That is enough—Time and respect for the rain forests that produce our newsprint do not permit a complete listing.





Monday, June 26, 2006

Women's Bioethics Blog

Routine HIV testing in the District of Columbia

I have often wondered if blood samples taken for laboratory tests or during hospitalization are screened for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). One could argue that routine screening of blood samples would be a good laboratory safety precaution; or that it could help catch infections in unsuspecting individuals, allowing early treatment and slowing the spread of the disease overall. A battery of questions flows: Could it also be argued that routine lab and hospital screening is too costly to be practical? Are there a set of guidelines for when HIV screening is performed? Are HIV screenings only performed when they must be ruled out as part of an explanation for a set of symptoms? Was my blood screened for HIV when I was hospitalized? Would I have been told only if my test was positive? Would routine hospital screening for HIV be considered a violation of privacy or other rights without patient consent?

Now the city of Washington, DC, which is believed to have the highest rate of HIV infection in the country (179.2/100,000 people), is urging mandatory HIV testing as part of routine health screening for all patients between the ages of 14 and 84. The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) has been pushing for physicians to routinely screen patients, but this is the first local effort of its kind. Starting tomorrow, the city will distribute 80,000 tests to community groups, doctors' offices, emergency rooms, and STD clinics. These are oral swab tests that produce results in twenty minutes, as opposed to blood tests that can take two weeks to process. According to Jason DeParle of the New York Times, this is "significant because many people who underwent the earlier tests never returned to learn the results, meaning those with the virus remained unaware of the risk they posed to others." I would take a guess that any test that can be processed in twenty minutes is also much less costly than one that gets sent to the lab for two weeks.

While the practicality of an oral test and the idea of routine testing potentially dissolve a few barriers toward HIV detection, there are still many questions to be addressed. Firstly, in a city of more than 550,000, how far will 80,000 tests go, and what happens when they run out? Susan Levine of the Washington Post reported on Saturday that the aim is to use up that supply by the end of the year, "which would mean reaching a fifth of their key population in the next six months." Both Patricia Nalls of the Women's Collective in Northwest Washington and Walter Smith of the DC Appleseed Center for Law and Justice expressed concerns about not having heard any detail about planning for necessary counseling and follow-up care for a newly diagnosed HIV-positive population.

It is also unclear as to whether routine screening does present a privacy issue. Alan Cross reported that the "recommendation met with some resistance from privacy advocates who felt that such a testing might end up stripping HIV-positive people of their privacy and a breach of confidentiality would make it difficult for them to lead normal lives."

Sources and further reading:

Deparle, Jason, "District of Columbia Urges Routine HIV Testing." New York Times, 25 June 2006, http://www.nytimes.com/2006/06/25/us/25hiv.html.

Levine, Susan, "DC Wants HIV Testing for All Residents 14 to 84." Washington Post, 24 June 2006, A01, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06/23/AR2006062301685.html.

Cross, Alan, "DE's new campaign to test 14 to 84 year-olds for HIV." Earthtimes.org, 25 June 2006, http://www.earthtimes.org/articles/show/7331.html.


Drug Maker Calls for Limiting Risk Information in Drug Ads


At a time when many are calling for more risk information in direct-to-consumer pharmaceutical ads, a new study from AstraZeneca puts a cap on the number of risks mentioned in TV spots before the consumer is overloaded.

Three is optimal. Four is good. Five is OK. Anything more than that, said the drug maker, and you start wandering into too-much-information territory.

But this runs contrary to counter to what the rest of the industry has discussed. The Food and Drug Administration has repeatedly asked for more risk information, and in remarks earlier this year the director of its drug marketing, advertising and communications division, Thomas Abrams, noted that 82% of pharmaceutical company violations in the past year were related to inadequate presentation of risk information.

Test may help "which came first" question in Alzheimer's

A new test may help scientists answer a perplexing "which came first" question about the development of Alzheimer's disease, possibly pointing the way to earlier diagnosis or even treatment.

Brain deposits of a small protein known as amyloid beta long have been associated with Alzheimer's. But scientists have been unable to determine whether the body begins producing too much of the protein or loses the ability to clear it away.

Now, a research team led by Dr. Randall J. Bateman at Washington University in St. Louis is poised to find that answer with a test that for the first time can monitor the protein.

An initial test of the new technique on six healthy volunteers determined that the protein is quickly produced and quickly cleared, keeping it in balance in the central nervous system, the researchers report in Monday's online issue of the journal Nature Medicine.

Does Anyone Remember what happened to the goose who laid the golden eggs?

In the Boston Globe:

Drowning in credit-card debt and student loans, young women are selling their eggs for big payoffs. But can they really make the right medical and moral decisions when they're tempted with $15,000?

Monday, June 19, 2006

St Kitt's or the Island of Dr. Moreau?

On the sun-splashed Caribbean island of St. Kitts, Yale University researchers are injecting millions of human brain cells into the heads of monkeys afflicted with Parkinson's disease.
In China, there are 29 goats running around on a farm with human cells coursing through their organs, a result of scientists dropping human blood cells into goat embryos.
The mixing of human and animal cells in the name of medicine has been going on for decades. People are walking around with pig valves in their hearts and scientists have routinely injected human cells into lab mice to mimic diseases.
But the research is becoming increasingly exotic as scientists work with the brains of mice, monkeys and other mammals and begin fiddling with the hot-button issue of cloning. Harvard University researchers are attempting to clone human embryonic cells in rabbit eggs.
Such work has triggered protests from social conservatives and others who fear the blurring of species lines, invoking the image of the chimera of Greek mythology, a monstrous mix of lion, goat and serpent.
During his State of the Union speech in January, President Bush called for a ban on "human cloning in all its forms" and "human-animal hybrids," labeling it one of the "most egregious abuses of medical research."
He didn't elaborate, but scientists working in the field believe that by "hybrids," the president meant creating living animals with human traits - something they say they aren't doing.
Other critics are calling for stricter regulations on the research.

Man's (and Woman's) Best Friend Saves Life

From the Washington Post: A Bite and Bark That Saved a Life -- Cellphone Chomp Called 911 for Beagle's Owner:

Belle Weaver is flying into the nation's capital today to receive an award for saving a family member's life. Before she leaves town, she'll meet with her congressman, accept a certificate autographed by a football great and bow her head to receive a medal. Stories such as hers, of heroism and quick thinking, are always inspiring. But this one has a twist, and not just because Belle is 3 years old -- she's a beagle. And she used her owner's cellphone to call 911. Her owner, Kevin Weaver, 34, was in the throes of a diabetic seizure, lying unconscious on his kitchen floor in Ocoee, Fla., when Belle located his phone and chomped down on the keypad, triggering a call.

The only thing emergency dispatchers heard was barking, but it was enough cause to send help, they reasoned. Weaver, a former flight attendant, woke up hours later in the hospital, weak and disoriented. Belle was there by his side, having finagled a ride in the ambulance.

Thursday, June 15, 2006

Are we unable to let go of our fears?

Blood shortages have been a problem in this country for some time now. There are always blood drives that try to entice and encourage people to donate blood for a good cause. From my point of view, I always found these blood drives to be a success, however the drives are not enough to lift the blood shortage to a sufficient status. According to an article written by Arthur Caplan, there seems to be an increasing shortage in blood supply owing to the fact that men who engage in same sex relationships are not permitted by law to donate blood. Apparently, since the AIDS epidemic became a threat in the mid 1980s, gay men have since not been allowed to even give their blood owing to their vulnerability to the disease. The government placed this law in effect when the epidemic was new and treatment was not available. Caplan feels that the shortage is owed to the fact that our government is still holding on to old fears by not allowing gay men to donate blood. With the advancement of medicine allowing for people to live longer and to combat the disease more efficiently, Caplan maintains that it is time for all people to give their blood by choice, and not be denied to do so just because of their sexual orientation. With the ever changing advancement of technology, AIDS and HIV can be detected earlier according to Caplan...so what should we be worried about? The government should realize that things are progressing at a positive rate in the medicine field. If we want these blood shortages to stop, the government should make some changes.Read more: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/13106365/

Wednesday, June 14, 2006

Combatting Obesity

Obesity has been on the rise since the late 1980’s. Today, approximately 65% of Americans are overweight, and over 30% of Americans are obese. The number of overweight children has also doubled. “According to some estimates, obesity results in thousands of deaths a year and accounts for $117 billion in U.S. health care expenses annually.”1
In an effort to combat the growing rate of obesity in the U.S., the FDA recently released the Keystone Report. In a world in which all of our portions are “super-sized,” the Keystone Report offers some solutions for controlling caloric intake, especially when eating outside the home. “Americans spend approximately 46 percent of their food budget on food prepared away from home and take in 32 percent of their calories from such foods.”1
The Keystone Report offers recommendations about how to change consumers eating behaviors. Specifically, the Report suggests increasing the marketing of lower calorie foods like fruits and vegetables and providing consumers with nutritional information. Although there has been an increase in the amount of nutritional information available to consumers, more improvements are possible. Most dining establishments still do not provide such nutritional information.
I agree that the FDA and other government agencies should continue to educate the public about health and dietary issues. However, because obesity rates are still on the rise, perhaps the government should also try to promote the benefits of eating more balanced meals at home. We will not see substantial improvements in the obesity rates until more education comes from within the home. Parents have to education themselves and their children about the benefits of eating healthy and exercising. Children sitting in front of the television hearing about exercising and eating more fruits and vegetables are not going to make any changes on their own. Unless parents talk to their children and lead by example, government initiatives will not make the improvements that they could.
Sources:
1http://www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/NEWS/2006/NEW01379.html
http://www.cnn.com/2006/HEALTH/diet.fitness/06/02/restaurants.obesity.ap/index.html

FDA Approves Thalidomide

The ratio of benefits vs. risks of a potential new drug is a main factor in deciding to approve a new drug. However, the acceptable ratio depends on the targeted condition or disease. For instance, numerous adverse effects are often associated with cancer treating medications. Due to the high mortality associated with cancer, these side effects are deemed acceptable compared to the death rates and other serious complications of cancer.
I read an article on CNN.com entitled “Thalidomide Approved for Cancer Treatment.” On May 25, 2006, the FDA approved the use of thalidomide in treating patients recently diagnosed with multiple myeloma. Thalidomide, in combination with dexamethasone, is to be used in treating multiple myeloma.
In the early sixties when thalidomide was used by pregnant women, it was discovered that thalidomide caused numerous birth defects. Specifically, it stunted the growth of fetal arms and legs and caused eye, ear, heart, and kidney defects. As a result, the use of thalidomide was banned worldwide in 1962.
Even today, with its FDA approval, thalidomide is being marketed under a “restricted distribution program.” Thalidomide labels display multiple warnings about the risk of birth defects. There is also a warning for male patients stating that it is unknown if thalidomide is present in semen. Due to the severe risks associated with thalidomide even the FDA provides information on its website about thalidomide and warns about the drug’s effects: “Do not take this drug if there is any possibility that you are, or may become, pregnant. Just one dose can cause severe birth defects.”
In addition to myeloma, thalidomide is also being examined in clinical trials as a treatment for a variety of solid tumors and blood cancers.
I found it interesting, and concerning, that a drug with such serious side effects will be used in hopes of prolonging the life of multiple myeloma patients. My concern is based on the CNN article’s suggestion that the success of the clinical trials is somewhat questionable and unknown. For the sake of those multiple myeloma patients that will take this medication in hopes of treating their condition, I hope that the efficacy of the drug outweighs the side effects.
Sources:
http://www.cnn.com/2006/HEALTH/conditions/05/25/thalidomide.cancer.ap/index.html
http://www.fda.gov/cder/news/thalidomide.htm
http://www.multiplemyeloma.org/treatments/3.04.html

Tuesday, June 13, 2006

Too Much Information -- DNA Home Kits

Imagine being able to order a genetic test over the Internet -- to see if you have inherited a predisposition to cancer or whether there might be a genetic component to your infertility -- without having to get approval from your doctor, consult a genetic counselor or risk the fallout that might result from filing an insurance claim.

Now imagine sitting alone at your home computer and receiving devastating news: test results that will forever change your life -- and your family's -- in ways you never anticipated.
Those are the promises and perils of the nascent, growing and largely unregulated phenomenon of direct-to-consumer (DTC) genetic tests. For the price of a mail order test kit containing swabs to scrape cells inside the cheek, nearly a dozen companies now offer curious consumers the chance, without ever seeing a doctor, to learn whether they carry genes for cancer, blood disorders or other diseases. Some companies are marketing personalized diet or skin care recommendations based on DNA analysis using tests that are not widely accepted in the scientific community.

For more, read on...

Hawking Says We Must Sail Beyond the Sunset To Survive


In a manner reminiscent of "To Sail Beyond the Sunset" (both the poem of Ulysses by Alfred Tennyson and the book by science fiction author Robert Heinlein), world reknowned astrophysicist Stephen Hawking has said that the survival of the human race depends on its ability to find new homes elsewhere in the universe because there's an increasing risk that a disaster will destroy the Earth.

Humans could have a permanent base on the moon in 20 years and a colony on Mars in the next 40 years, the British scientist told a news conference. "We won't find anywhere as nice as Earth unless we go to another star system," added Hawking, who arrived in Hong Kong to a rock star's welcome Monday. Tickets for his lecture planned for Wednesday were sold out.

He added that if humans can avoid killing themselves in the next 100 years, they should have space settlements that can continue without support from Earth.

"It is important for the human race to spread out into space for the survival of the species," Hawking said. "Life on Earth is at the ever-increasing risk of being wiped out by a disaster, such as sudden global warming, nuclear war, a genetically engineered virus or other dangers we have not yet thought of."

Friday, June 09, 2006

UN hears about HPV Vaccine

I am pleased to have been invited to speak at the UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Division for the Advancement of Women on June 6, 2006. The meeting was chaired by Ms. Rachel Mayanja, UN Assistant Secretary General and Special Advisor to UN Secretary General Kofi Annan on Gender Issues and Women's Advancement (OSAGI). Over 20 high-ranking UN officials attended the meeting. Novel developments of particular concern to women include human egg and other tissue markets, as well as the recently announced vaccine for cervical cancer, a disease which kills approximately 300,000 women each year--mostly in the developing world. I argued that it is vital for women, who have a special stake in bioethical issues, to come together to promote a thoughtful application of biotechnology to improve the status of women's lives, to safeguard women's bodies from harm, and to ensure that social policies regarding women are appropriately recognized and incorporated into public policy.
Read more about:www.iheu.org/bioethics

The Capitalization of Medical Services?

One morning last week I was rudely awakened by the blaring news report coming from my radio alarm about a private medical practice offering, for an extra charge, preferential patient treatment that would include services such as next-day appointments, three-minute return phone calls, and real-time access to a doctor by cell phone or email. I was horrified. If some patients pay extra fees for priority service, isn't response time and level of service for patients who can not pay extra fees necessarily de-prioritized and slowed? My jaw dropped a little further when I heard the doctor speaking for the practice rationalize the idea by explaining that without the extra revenue derived from premium services, his practice would be out-of-business within the next year or two.

I was immediately reminded of an issue I worked on when I was an advocate for artists and cultural organizations. In 2001, the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (now the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services) implemented a $1000 premium processing fee for non-immigrant visa applications. This service worked in favor of businesses who could pay the fee to have the applications of new foreign employees processed in 15 days, but it significantly lengthened the time it took to process non-premium application (to as much as 120 days). As a result, the visa applications of international artists who could not pay the fee were delayed enough that some missed their own performances in the U.S. and many cultural institutions experienced booking difficulties.

I was a little groggy when I heard this news and I had missed the first half of the story, so I later Googled around for a matching news article with the information I missed. I didn't find an exact match, but I did find a number of other articles about the phenomenon—that is, concierge medicine or “pay-for-care” services. Concierge-style medical practices charge an annual fee of anywhere from $700 to $6000 for the patient conveniences mentioned above, and additional per-visit fees of $50 to $200 depending on the service provided. Many patients who utilize concierge medical services claim that these fee-based conveniences save them aggravation in obtaining care, provide them with better quality health care, and save them money and time in the long-run. Many of these patients also keep their regular health insurance to cover major and emergency medical needs.

I couldn't help but wonder, if I as a patient could pay the extra fees, why should I, on principle, have to pay anything on top of what I'm already shelling out for health insurance and copays, just to get decent service? Furthermore, would it not be selfish of me to opt for premium service knowing that medical care resources are limited and I would in effect be taking away a level of service from patients who can not afford extra costs?

Should a line be drawn between different kinds of services, those for which premium service is stratified by cost and those for which levels of service must be prioritized by something else? I thought to myself, it's one thing to charge extra fees for a service that does not directly infringe on the rights of an individual. I don't have a problem with the idea of stratefying cost according to speed of package delivery, as it is unlikely to affect any critical aspect of my life (like my health), and the use of premium services do not strain the resources of the delivery company. Health care services are sometimes prioritized by urgency of medical need, for example, in the emergency room, or when my physician will give me a same-day appointment because I have been running a high fever for several days. But once someone else can out-prioritize me by paying more, medical urgency goes out the window.

It then occurred to me that it may be more ethical to run a purely pay-for-service practice, as opposed to a practice that offered fee-based services for those who could afford them but still accepted patients who could not. (I'm not sure exactly how the practice on the news operated.) Some doctors who run concierge-style medical practices in fact claim that they are better able to care for their patients because they see fewer patients without sacrificing revenue and save time by not having to submit health insurance claims for patients. Declining rates of insurance reimbursements for providers was also cited as incentive to run concierge practices.

Still, the existence of a few concierge-style medical practices creates the potential for skew in who gets the better medical care and an environment of “you get what you pay for.” I can imagine that as things currently stand only a very small percentage of the population could or would be willing to pay several thousand more dollars a year for medical care. I am reminded of a conversation I had with a Philadelphia-based psychotherapist about the administrative and cost issues of insurance supplementation for mental health services: she told me that many of her colleagues had chosen to move their practices to Main Line areas, where patients would be likely pay for services not covered by insurance. This was not to suggest that those therapists were not aware that they were potentially contributing to an overall situation of better care for the “haves,” but that they had perhaps had made a very difficult personal choice, an ethical leap, that the benefits to perhaps themselves or their families or the future of their practices outweighed the issues (and their abilities to operate within them) presented in today's landscape of psychological and medical care in the United States. Though I certainly do not believe that the idea of concierge medical practices or psychological services available only in economically advantaged areas is a viable solution to the critical issues of a medical care coverage system that is groaning under its own weight, I do believe that it is worthwhile considering the idea that concierge medical practices are a valid development, or an ethical/pragmatic response to the current landscape of medical care coverage. This also forces consideration of the fact that, as things now stand, U.S. citizens are hardly on a level playing field in terms of medical coverage and quality of care, and I can't help but wonder that if pay-for-care medical service was the norm, things might not be that much different than they are now.

Some interesting news stories about concierge medicine:
http://www.bradenton.com/mld/bradenton/news/nation/14477842.htm
http://cbs2chicago.com/health/local_story_125141203.html
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6885323/site/newsweek/


and from the Miami Herald.

The DaVinci Code and Women's Bioethics


Maybe it's a little bit of stretch, but what does the book and the movie The DaVinci Code have to do with Women's Bioethics? How about this for arguments: "...the latest challenge to women's lowly status in religion. The female place in sacred history, according to a group of researchers, goes beyond wife, mother and follower." The pro-life movement sees it this way: 'The Da Vinci Code is a piece of propaganda which follows the same pattern as the revolution that gave us abortion and the rest of our promiscuous culture. The fallout of that revolution ... could lead to the spiritual deaths of millions more."


What are your thoughts? Does anybody else see more connections? Or is this too much of stretch?



Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Recombinant Vaccine Approved by FDA

U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) today approved a Quadrivalent Human Papillomavirus Recombinant Vaccine. It is the first and only vaccine to prevent cervical cancer and vulvar and vaginal pre-cancers caused by HPV types 16 and 18 and to prevent low-grade and pre-cancerous lesions and genital warts caused by HPV types 6, 11, 16 and 18 and is developed by Merck and will be marketed under trade name Gardasil.

Arthur Allen does a nice job of discussing some things we should be thinking about in his Slate article: And Now, the HPV Vaccine: Warts and all (http://www.slate.com/id/2143304/) :

"...how to get the vaccine to the women and girls who need it most—poor, uneducated women and those in the developing world. "None of us are going to be happy if the only women who get the vaccine are the same women who are already getting regular screens for cervical cancer," John Schiller, one of the vaccine's inventors, told me at his National Institutes of Health laboratory. The Vaccines for Children program, a Clinton-era entitlement, will probably make the vaccine available for free to poor children in the United States. But social conservatives like Focus on the Family leader James Dobson have opposed making vaccination mandatory, believing vaccination might lower barriers to teen sex.In a roundabout way, this prudery may keep the vaccine out of reach of poor girls. Research and experience have shown that only mandatory-vaccination laws—which typically increase vaccination rates by 10 to 15 percent—get even cheap vaccines to the poor. Given the politics, state legislatures and public health boards may shy from requiring HPV vaccine for middle-school entry."

And Justice Healthcare for All....

This falls under the category of 'no big surprise' : The federal government should guarantee that all Americans have basic health insurance coverage, says a committee set up by Congress to find out what people want when it comes to health care.

"Assuring health care is a shared social responsibility," says the interim report of the Citizens' Health Care Working Group, a 14-member committee that went to 50 communities and heard from 23,000 people.

The committee describes its recommendations as a framework. The recommendations don't say who would pay for universal health coverage or how much it would cost. The concept of government-guaranteed coverage runs counter to the Bush administration's position that consumers should bear more responsibility for their initial medical expenses.


Thursday, June 08, 2006

Shades of X-Men and other augmentations


When Camille Walters plays soccer, her normally brown eyes have a spooky red tint – that’s because of the contact lens designed to give this athlete an edge.
That's because the 15-year-old wears tinted contact lenses that block certain wavelengths of light and help athletes see better. Oh, and they look cool, too.

But does these lenses give some athletes an unfair advantage? The associations that govern high school and college sports don't think so, but they're keeping an eye on the lenses.

Jerry Diehl, assistant director of the National Federation of State High School Associations in Indianapolis, Indiana, said his group doesn't believe the lenses provide the competitive advantage that Nike claims.

The federation allows the lenses and puts them in the same category as sunglasses or corrective lenses. The NCAA also allows the sports lenses because it considers them similar to sunglasses.

But Diehl said he's worried about the perception of an unfair advantage.

"If one affluent team can get this, it forces everybody else to go out and do that," Diehl said. "Is it really something that makes a difference? In this instance, at this juncture anyway, it doesn't seem to be any better or any worse than allowing what is already under the rule."

Dr. William Jones of Nashville said price will keep some athletes from buying the lenses, but he expects them to be popular on high school athletics teams in wealthier school districts.

Hands Off My _________ (Fill in the blank) !!!!

Between a post in the Sunday Times a few days ago about IVF clinics shutting down because sperm donors are not willing to donate unless they can maintain their anonymity and an article today in the Boston Globe about the ethical considerations of egg donations (Women who donate eggs have to take drugs that hyperstimulate the ovaries and undergo minor surgery; this puts them at risk for side effects, yet there is no immediate benefit to them or anyone else -- an uneasy and probably unprecedented combination), it's interesting that donors of both sexes are protesting. This poses an interesting dilemma and suggests that we perhaps need to seek stem cells from other places.

Tuesday, June 06, 2006

Progressive Bioethics?

A recent posting invited progressive bioethics scholars to participate in a private briefing at the upcoming ASBH summer conference in Albany. But it begs the question of “what do you mean by progressive?” The Center for American Progressive has done an inspired job of defining what they call “timeless progressive principles: human dignity, critical optimism, equity and social justice.” The board of WBP would add explicit support for women’s reproductive freedom (our mission states we are pro-choice and pro-science.) How this all translates into public policy is our challenge. We hope you’ll join us.

-- Kathryn Hinsch

Calling All Progressive Bioethics Scholars

Do you consider yourself a progressive bioethics scholar? Are you interested in getting more politically involved? Will you be attending the ASBH Summer conference in Albany, NY entitled “Bioethics & Politics - The Future of Bioethics in a Divided Democracy”? If so, you should email info@womensbioethics.org to get an invitation to a pre-conference (July 13th 11-1pm – lunch included) private, invitation only briefing and round table discussion hosted by Jonathan Moreno, Center for American Progress and Kathryn Hinsch, Women's Bioethics Project. The briefing is not open to the press.

Created in God’s genetically modified image?


From Science and Theology magazine:

A priest, a rabbi, and an Islamic scholar walk into a room full of scientists …

Sound like a modern twist to a politically incorrect joke? Actually it happened in 1999 in Rockville, Md., and serves as an ideal metaphor for the growing cooperation between science and religion. The three religious leaders were among 11 experts called by the National Bioethics Advisory Commission to give religious perspectives on human stem cell research.

The witnesses agreed on little. But it was evident that a fundamental question had gone unchanged, at least since Nathaniel Hawthorne’s cautionary short story “The Birthmark” was published 163 years ago. Should scientists do something simply because they can? As biotechnology enables us to do more and more, that question becomes ever more finely parsed. From 1866 to this day, no one has looked askance at Gregor Mendel’s cross-pollination of pea pods. Yet in the spring of 1994, biotechnology firm Calgene’s genetically modified Flavr Savr tomato drew salvos from activists who charged that the company was producing “Frankenfood” that could harm human health and disrupt the food chain.

Human Enhancement Technologies and Human Rights (HETHR) Conference reports

Although I was unable to attend the Human Enhancement Technologies and Human Rights (HETHR) conference over Memorial Day at Stanford , it sounded like a fascinating discussion -- and I've been reading the reviews, including William Saletan's critique on Slate, but the article that caught my attention was Dale Carrico's response to William Saletan, entitled, "Thanks for the Back-Handed Compliments". There is one quote that stands out in mind: "...the real policy difficulties are matters of ensuring that everybody has access to good consensus scientific information about emerging medicine, and that the risks, costs, and benefits of these developments are all fairly shared among all the stakeholders to that development. Thrusting aside all the sometimes silly neologisms, the futurisms, posthumanisms, and technophiliasms, there is something deeply and intimately human about the traffic between biology and cultural/technological practice that produce the fragile and lovely personages that house our hopes and fears and memories."

Monday, June 05, 2006

Pharmacist's Suit Dismissed in Federal Court

Wal-Mart Stores Inc. acted appropriately by firing a Catholic pharmacist who refused to interact with patients seeking birth control prescriptions, a federal judge ruled Thursday.

Shabaz said Wal-Mart and Medical Staffing Network accommodated Noesen's religious opposition to contraception by having other pharmacists fill prescriptions. But he said Noesen went too far by putting customers who called about birth control on hold indefinitely and refusing to get service for those who showed up in person without notifying other pharmacists.

Medical Privacy Laws -- All Bark, No Bite....

Rob Stein of the Washington Post writes: Critics say lax enforcement may limit compliance. In the three years since Americans gained federal protection for their private medical information, the Bush administration has received thousands of complaints alleging violations but has not imposed a single civil fine and has prosecuted just two criminal cases.

We Are All Hybrids....

[Thanks for R. Alta Charo for the title]

By Rick Weiss of the Washington Post:

So you think you are the self-reliant type.

A rugged individualist.

Well, give it up. You'd be nothing without the trillions of microbial minions toiling in your large intestine, performing crucial physiological functions that your highfalutin human cells wouldn't have a clue how to do.

Sunday, June 04, 2006

X-Men: The Last Stand

The Women's Bioethics Project will be conducting a series of online focus groups examining the bio-ethical implications of the recently released “X-Men: The Last Stand.” Plot outline: A “cure” for mutancy threatens to alter the course of history. For the first time, mutants have a choice to retain their uniqueness, though it isolates and alienates them or give up their powers and become human. Directed by Brett Ratner.

If you would like to participate, please email bookclub@womensbioethics.org with your name, age, gender, and geographical location. We need your demographic information to be sure we have a representative sample but all responses will be compiled without attribution. The groups will be held mid-July and the results presented to the WBP advisory committees and state legislators bioethics working group. Please consider participating in this important project. Incentive: WBP coffee mug to all participants.

[Submitted by Kathryn Hinsch]

Quote of the day....


"All the marvels and wonders of technology can amount to nothing unless it elevates humans to their highest potential" --

Today's quote is by Jacque Fresco, an inventor who I had the pleasure of meeting at a conference a few years ago. He describles himself most often as a multi-disciplinarian or “generalist” -- a student of many inter-related fields. He is a prolific inventor, having spent his entire life (he is now 89 years old) conceiving of and devising inventions on various scales which entail the use of innovative technology.

The quote comes from the film Future by Design, a documentary film by Academy Award® nominated Hollywood filmmaker William Gazecki --the film is a visually and intellectually engaging exploration of one man’s vision of a future where war is outdated, there is no shortage of any necessary resource, and our focus as a species is sustainability. But far from presenting a vision of Utopia, this documentary demonstrates a “possible future” -- with real and viable alternatives to our current paradigm of militarism and commercialism.

In the Future by Design, all systems work together. The personal, social, economic, industrial and governance arenas are all interconnected and balanced into one functional system. The Future by Design is a true participatory democracy, where each member of the society has the opportunity to input their needs, opinions and preferences into the central computer, which then assesses and analyzes all information to determine the use of resources in manufacturing distribution of goods and services. For an inspiring look at humanity's potential, check it out at futurebydesign.org.

[Models & Photos by Jacque Fresco & Roxanne Meadows]


Friday, June 02, 2006

I wonder if they'd refuse to sell Viagra, too?

Washington State Regulators endorse "refuse and refer" for morning-after pill. Druggists who personally oppose morning-after birth-control pills could refuse to sell them under a rule endorsed today by state pharmacy regulators.

The Board of Pharmacy's move mirrored the preference of the state pharmacy association but angered abortion- and women's-rights groups, and defied the wishes of Gov. Christine Gregoire.

Lisa Stone JD, Board member of the WBP and Executive Director of the Northwestern Women's Law Center had this to say about the rule: “If a pharmacist refuses to fill a prescription for emergency contraception, that's illegal sex discrimination. And it's wrong. But that's not all -- the Pharmacy Board's own records show that patients have been denied antibiotics and anti-depressants, among other drugs. I respect and admire pharmacists, and appreciate the skill and training they bring to the profession. But they have no place deciding what medications any patient may or may not take because they object to the medication, to the prescriber or to the patient standing before them. Under this proposed rule, a pharmacist could refuse to fill prescriptions based on ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, disability -- you name it, the choice of whether a patient received lawfully prescribed medicine would be in the hands of the pharmacist, not the doctor, and definitely not the patient.”

Look, up in the sky! It's a bird! It's a plane! No, it's...

[Hat tip to R. Alta Charo for the great header] Under the category of "this would change everything": As bizarre as it may seem, the sample jars brimming with cloudy, reddish rainwater in Godfrey Louis's laboratory in southern India may hold, well, aliens. In April, Louis, a solid-state physicist at Mahatma Gandhi University, published a paper in the prestigious peer-reviewed journal Astrophysics and Space Science in which he hypothesizes that the samples -- water taken from the mysterious blood-colored showers that fell sporadically across Louis's home state of Kerala in the summer of 2001 -- contain microbes from outer space.

Of Mice and Men and those in between...

Interesting article in Slate yesterday about the problem(s) with animal testing and how animal rights activists are questioning whether or not animal testing is necessary anymore and that evidence points to a need for new designs in pharmaceutical testing.

In a similar vein, Francoise Baylis gave an awesome telelecture today at the University of Vermont on "Ethical Issues in Chimera Research and Stem cell therapies for Human Neurodegenerative Disorders", an area which has been of great interest to me ever since I started researching the issue for my thesis at McGill (published here). Some articles that both she and I have written at actionbioscience.com outline the issues that scientists and researchers will be facing.



HPV debate: Virginity or Death?

Merck and GlaxoSmithKline have the answer to the threat of human papilloma virus in women; that is new vaccines that can help prevent it before it infects a system. HPV is an STD that can often lead to cancer in women and has diagnosed 10,000 American women a year. This new vaccine that can be administered to preteens before they become active is the cause of great controversy for Christian groups. They assume that this type of vaccine will allow children to engage in sexual activity before marriage. The article is in opposition of such a notion. The author argues that the real issue for Christian Conservatives is this debate is women’s virginity, just as it was in the original debate over abortion. HPV can be used as a great scare tactic for Christian conservatives because is it not prevented through the use of condoms. However, opponents of this vaccine are essentially holding that having sex before marriage is worse than having cancer later. The conservatives use the example of a 13 year old pregnant girl in Florida who had a child when she was a child herself. The article explains that she was too young to be having sex or an abortion, but it fails to explain why wasn’t too young to be forced to go through childbirth. Right- wing Christians consider that women should abstain from sexual activity. They try to achieve this through the use of fear. This is why people who are pro-life will not join with pro-choicers to lessen numbers of abortions by making birth control available. This has little to do with protecting human life and it is more focused on making sure women are tied to marriage. Read more here.

--
Posted by Ana Lita to Women's Bioethics Blog at 6/02/2006 12:52:00 PM

And it might kill you, too.

This news report in today's NYT highlights the harrowing fact that female genital cutting, sometimes referred to as female circumcision, increases by 50% the likelihood that the woman or her baby will die during childbirth.

Those of us who are concerned with women's health and welfare would do well to consider this issue. Thinking about the amount of ink and anguish we spill in the US about the "mommy wars"--when this kind of thing is going on in the world--makes me crazy.

Wednesday, May 31, 2006

In Memoriam: Ronald Cranford


I'm sad to announce that a friend passed away today: Ronald Cranford, Professor of Neurology, University of Minnesota Medical School; Senior Physician and Assistant Chief of Neurology, Hennepin County Medical Center; and Faculty Associate, Center for Bioethics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota. I had the privilege of meeting Ronnie in Newport shortly after I had done the Gray vs. Romeo case in Rhode Island; we were both lecturing at the Newport Hospital Ethics Conference on Life's Final Days: Rights, Responsibilities, and Resources and we were introduced by our mutual friend, attorney Paul Armstrong, the New Jersey lawyer (now a superior court judge) who represented the families of Karen Ann Quinlan and Nancy Ellen Jobes. Intelligent, passionate in his beliefs, and not one to be intimidated by naysayers, he will be missed. May he rest in peace and in the arms of the angels.



Wednesday, May 24, 2006

See? We told you sex was bad. . . .

Here is an opinion piece about the new human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine in yesterday's NYT. The vaccine, Merck's Gardasil, is fully effective against the virus that causes most cases of cervical cancer. Expected to cost between $300 and $500 for a series of three shots, use of the vaccine is expected to draw fire from the right wing as yet another practice that encourages premarital sex. (Some on the right have so far said only that they oppose mandatory vaccination for school entry, but support widespread availability of the vaccine.)

Here's the rub: the vaccine is more effective when it's given between the ages of 10 to 15 than between the ages of 16 and 23; so to maximize its usefulness, experts are recommending vaccination be completed before a person (male or female) becomes sexually active. . . which means vaccinating children against an STD.

If we can prevent cervical cancer by use of this vaccine, is it ethical to decide not to do so--because of concerns about promoting teenage sex? Will Medicaid pay for the vaccine, or will only those who can afford it be protected from cervical cancer? Stay tuned.

Nancy Berlinger has a piece on the Hastings Center's Bioethics Forum here, and Katha Pollitt has a great (year-old) piece on this issue here.

Friday, May 19, 2006

Happy Birthday to the WBP Blog!


It's been a year this month since we launched the Women's Bioethics Project Blog and what a great year it has been! Thank you to Kathryn Hinsch, the East and West Coast Board of Directors, my fellow bloggers, and the academic community for lending their support. We are always looking to build our team, add voices, and expand our knowledge, so if you are interested in blogging for us, please contact Linda MacDonald Glenn [lindaglenn(at)ethicsconsult.com] or Sue Trinidad [sue.trinidad(at)gmail].

Godless Science?

In an article recently published by *The Philadelphia Inquirer* Arthur Caplan discusses the risks of biogenetics. Arthur Caplan reassures the reader that there is no reason for anyone to fear for the advancement of biogenetics. With the many positive outcomes that biogenetics promises, Caplan tells us that "...our society would be foolish and cruel to forbid or ban genetic research given the needs of the sick, starving, impaired and those of future generations for solutions and treatments. Will we really turn away from those who literally are dying before our eyes, or who will die before our children's eyes, simply out of fear of scientist guiding public policy?." Many people who are against biogenetics are people who hold religious beliefs. There is no need, Art Caplan says, to fear that scientists will potentially be leading public policy (with respect to biogenetics), because it is quite foolish for anyone to think that scientists can just create another life being by themselves. If anything, there seems to be a misunderstanding of scientists; that they are mostly not affiliated with religion and that they go about testing extremes every chance that they get. Caplan corrects this stereotype by mentioning that many scientists are actually religious with respect to humankind for the love of other beings, the love of preventing fellow brothers from not becoming sick or becoming sick. Scientists are out to save our society from diseases such as sickle cell, SARS, avian flu, HIV, TB, and many others.

Caplan calls for a bridge between the sciences and the humanities and also urges the scientists to reveal themselves to the public and show people that they are also human, "...that they stand shoulder to shoulder with all of us in wanting a better world". Read more here (Link has been added--sorry for the oversight--sbt):

Sunday, May 07, 2006

Conservative opposition to contraception gaining traction?

Today's New York Times Magazine includes this article by Russell Shorto. Shorto describes efforts by conservative groups in the United States to block information about, and access to, contraception.

The article outlines some of the reasons that contraception is becoming a political battleground (again). It's due in part to technological and pharmacological advances that blur the line between abortion and contraception . . . and in part to the increasing influence of conservative religious beliefs on public policy.

Many people are watching Roe; Shorto's article suggests that we ought to pay attention to Griswold.

Wednesday, May 03, 2006

Dying Patients right to access experimental drugs

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ruled yesterday that terminally ill patients have a constitutional right to obtain experimental drugs before the Food and Drug Administration has decided whether to approve them. The court held that drugs that have passed the first phase of FDA review should be made available if they might save someone's life -- in a reverse application the Supreme Court's holding in Cruzan, Judge Judith W. Rogers wrote "If there is a protected liberty interest in self-determination that includes a right to refuse life-sustaining treatment, even though this will hasten death, then the same liberty interest must include the complementary right of access to potentially life-sustaining medication, in light of the explicit protection accorded 'life' " .

Tuesday, May 02, 2006

Are 'Lie-Detectors' a scam?

From the Washington Post today: In the popular mind, fueled by Hollywood representations, polygraphs are lie-detection machines that can peer inside people's heads to determine whether they are telling the truth.

The scientific reality is far different: The machines measure various physiological changes, including in blood pressure and heart rate, to determine when subjects are getting anxious, based on the idea that deception involves an element of anxiety. But because an emotion such as anxiety can be triggered by many factors other than lying, experts worry that the tests can overlook smooth-talking liars while pointing a finger at innocent people who just happen to be rattled.

My question is will the new neuroetechnologies that we posted about earlier be any better?

Too Early to Declare Victory In the War Against Breast Cancer?

Abigail Trafford opines that it might be too early to declare victory in the war against breast cancer.

More States Screening for Post Partum Depression

As we had posted earlier, New Jersey passed a law mandating screening for postpartum depression, but the Washington Post reports that more states are making strides in raising awareness of the disorder and screening more mothers for it. But what about follow-up or feedback mechanisms to see if this legislation is really working?

Sunday, April 23, 2006

Less Invasive Glucose Monitoring for Diabetics

For those of us who have diabetes or loved ones with diabetes, great news in the Washington Post today: new devices promise diabetics a new measure of freedom and are expected to be widely available in the United States by late this summer. Instead of needle sticks several times a day and night, a patch worn on the abdomen carries a tiny wire that pokes through the skin to measure glucose in cellular fluid; the patch is worn for several days, wirelessly transmitting information to a receiver the size of a mobile phone, before it is replaced with a new one.

The Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation is launching a series of independent studies designed to test manufacturer claims about the new devices and provide information on their worth. Among the big questions are how much they can cut rates of hospitalization, car accidents caused by drivers with low blood sugar and the many other problems attributable to diabetes.

Wednesday, April 19, 2006

India's New Battle Against Imperialism by the Pharmaceutical Companies

Glenn McGee, the director of Alden March Bioethics Institute in Albany, draws a parallel between the outsourcing of clinical trials of Western pharmaceutical companies and the history of British imperialism in India. As the necessity for clinical trials increase with the discovery of new drugs, people willing to enroll in clinical trials from developed countries decreases. Pharmaceutical companies, therefore, are moving clinical trials to the largely illiterate populations of the developing and under-developed countries in exchange for a miniscule amount of US/European currencies. The disparity between the exchange rates reduces the cost of the trials drastically as well as providing a large (in terms of Indian currency) income to the participants in these clinical trials.

But that is not the primary reason why McGee claims that Gandhi would have led a protest march against clinical trials if he had been alive. McGee points out that a majority of the enrollees in these clinical trials have no idea what drugs they are taking. Even though these subjects are giving their consent, they have no idea to what they are consenting. In some cases, the drug has not been proven safe before the trials. McGee mentions the case of the unapproved clinical trial in which 435 women were given a fertility drug that was not cleared for testing on human subjects. Clinical trials too offensive to American research subjects are being proffered to the residents of India. McGee wonders how long until the people of India rise up against this new form of imperialism.

Read more

Jeopardizing the Reproductive Health of Guatemalan Women

In this week’s issue of the Lancet (The Lancet 2006; 367:1227-1228; subscription required but access is free), Hannah Roberts reports on the increasing practice of hymen reconstruction on women in Guatemala to “restore virginity.” I learned of this article and issue reading Stuart Rennie's globalbioethicsblog. This “intimate surgery” as it is called is accounted for because: “Women are expected to be virgins when they marry; in some communities blood evidence from the wedding night is still required for verification by the family. The profound societal significance of bridal virginity is such that women are prepared to compromise their physical health to remain socially acceptable.” Those who perform this expensive surgery (app. $1000US) are not usually licensed health care workers, are found through hand-painted advertisements on walls, provide unsafe operating conditions, and rarely provide follow-up appointments. Women who have undergone this procedure are showing up in hospitals presenting with infections, hemorrhaging, incontinence, fistulas, and extreme pain during sexual intercourse.

Roberts reports that Guatemala has one of the worst records in Central America for reproductive health with high rates of maternal and infant mortality and low levels of knowledge about contraception. (She cites: In some parts of the country, 42·1% of the population had not heard of HIV/AIDS; 2·3% of the women chose condoms as their preferred method of contraception; just over 40% of women had used any form of contraception at all.) This situation is referred to as a crisis.

While activists campaign for stronger legal regulation of reproductive-health information and services, and have support for such in the Guatemala Parliament, the President of the country and the Roman Catholic church are thwarting efforts towards the goal of women’s reproductive health.

Guatemala has a population of approximately 13 million people and is the most populous country in Central America. The population is approximately half indigenous, Mayan. Spanish is the official language but Mayan languages are spoken alongside Spanish. The distribution of income is highly unequal with perhaps 75% of the population below the poverty line. From 1960, the people of Guatemala endured 36 years of bloody civil war between a series of military regimes and anti-government guerrillas which left up to 200,000 people dead and many “disappeared.” According to MADRE, “Behind the smokescreen of "fighting communism," military groups trained and funded by the US killed mostly Indigenous people and destroyed 440 Mayan villages. More than a million people were uprooted from their homes and over a quarter million became refugees in surrounding countries.” In 1992, Rigoberta Menchu, a Mayan rights activist was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize. In 1996, Guatemalans celebrated the signing of Peace Accords, however, the country is still marked by violence and corruption and according to Amnesty International, has witnessed over 1500 brutal killings of women since 2001. There has been a marked lack of thorough and impartial investigation into these and other violent crimes against women. The recent AA report (April 1 2006) concludes that: ”the State of Guatemala is not taking effective action to eliminate gender discrimination in the criminal justice system, ensure proper investigations and bring those responsible for the killing of women to justice. This failure has meant increased suffering on the part of relatives of women killed, which Amnesty International believes amounts to cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment.”

During the civil war, the Roman Church and other religious organizations took a leadership role in giving material, psychological and spiritual aid to victims; sometimes it engaged in political activities and church members were disappeared and murdered. But Church teachings about the morality of reproduction are affecting public health policy in the country to the detriment of women’s reproductive health. Women of the country overwhelming want access to family planning information and services, but it is not being provided. Moreover, international funding for reproductive health programs has been cut off as a consequence of the current US administration's hostility to modern family-planning methods. See: http://www.reproductiverights.org/pdf/guatemala.pdf

Tuesday, April 18, 2006

Meet Noelle, the Pregnant Robot



Noelle, the first lifelike, birthing simulator is being used in a growing number of medical schools and hospital maternity wards.

The full-sized mannequin is in demand because medicine is rapidly abandoning the ethically questionable centuries-old tradition of using patients as guinea pigs, turning instead to high-tech simulations.

The Institute of Medicine estimates that as many as 98,000 U.S. patients die annually from preventable medical errors. Obviously, it's better to make a mistake on a $20,000 robot than a live patient -- Other companies make lifelike mannequins to train paramedics in emergencies, but Noelle appears to be the only high-tech, pregnant model available. Noelle models range from a $3,200 basic version to a $20,000 computerized Noelle that best approximates a live birth.


[image from http://ctheory.concordia.ca/hacking/pregnant.html]

Breast Cancer Breakthrough

Good news for women: A large government sponsored study of nearly 20,000 postmenopausal women found that raloxifene (marketed under the name of Evista) reduces their chance of developing breast cancer as effectively as tamoxifen, the only drug previously shown to reduce the risk, but is less likely to cause serious side effects such as uterine cancer and blood clots.

Because an estimated 500,000 women use raloxifene to reduce the risk of osteoporosis, many will be more comfortable using it for breast cancer protection, several experts predicted.

"It's terrific," said Susan Love, a breast cancer expert at the University of California at Los Angeles. "This gives us another drug that we can use to prevent breast cancer that is less risky than the only other drug we had."

Several experts, however, urged caution, saying that the advantage of raloxifene remains unclear and that more research is needed to prove the drug reduced the overall risk over longer periods.

Saturday, April 15, 2006

New Jersey New Moms to be screened for depression

New Jersey Governor Jon S. Corzine on Thursday signed into law a measure that aims to provide help to women who become depressed after giving birth. Health care professionals will be required to educate expecting mothers and their families about postpartum depression and to screen new moms for the disorder.

While the intent of the bill is noble, there are some obvious problems with the language of the bill and monitoring mechanisms --
First, postpartum depression can happen anytime within the first year after childbirth -- the language of screening "new mothers for postpartum depression symptoms prior to discharge from the birthing facility and at the first few postnatal check-up visits;" is pretty vague -- the first two, three visits? -- it deosn't create a specific standard of care.

Secondly, there is no follow-up or feedback mechanism --From a research ethics viewpoint, there needs to be put in a formalized report process which protects the anonymity and privacy of the individual, yet collects sufficient to data to indicate that program is being effective -- that the message is getting through to the intended audience -- otherwise, how can it be shown that the legislation will have any effect? Without that, it amounts to more of a 'political' issue than a 'medical' issue.

Finally, the part of the bill that requires "Physicians, nurse midwives and other licensed health care professionals providing prenatal and postnatal care to women shall include fathers and other family members, as appropriate, in both the education and treatment processes" doesn't address issues of medical confidentiality, an important issue with HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 ) these days. This is a particular difficulty with legislatures mandating certain actions -- the legislature is telling the professionals do something that could be contrary to other laws (such as HIPAA) .

Friday, April 14, 2006

Breast implants linked to increased suicide risk

More evidence reported here that suggests that suicide is more common among women who have breast augmentation surgery than those who don't. Their risk of death for most causes, though, is lower than the general population's. . . one wonders how socioeconomic status plays into these stats.

Thursday, April 13, 2006

UK team to open "designer baby" clinic

According to this article in the News Telegraph, a UK team plans to open a clinic that will specialize in the creation of "saviour siblings"--that is, children conceived so as to provide a source of genetically matched organs (including blood, etc.) for a sick brother or sister.

Parents doing this isn't new news--it's happened in the US and in the UK. What's new is a clinic designed for this specific purpose.

And while we're on the topic, if you haven't already read Jodi Picoult's book, My Sister's Keeper, this would be a good time . . . . check out the new WBP book club here.

Tuesday, April 11, 2006

WBP Launches Book Club Campaign: Stories about cloning and “designer babies” bring bioethical issues to life

The Women’s Bioethics Project (WBP) today announced the launch of a book club program designed to empower women to explore the dramatic ways in which emerging biotechnologies are affecting peoples’ lives. The program provides book club support materials that go beyond asking literary questions to promote discussion of bioethical issues, raising provocative questions such as, “Is it ethical to conceive a child as an organ donor for her sister?”
The format of the WBP book club program is designed to inspire participants to draw their own conclusions about the kind of world they would like to live in. It also encourages readers to consider some of the proposed advantages of new technological advances in biomedicine and genetic engineering, as well as to look at whether it would be possible to minimize the undesirable effects these technologies may have on individuals and society at large.

“Through a series of interviews we’ve learned that women are eager to discuss bioethical issues if they are put in a context that shows how they directly affect their lives,” said Kathryn Hinsch, founder of the Women’s Bioethics Project. “Many women we spoke with said they wanted to participate in discussions about these topics, but only if it didn’t require additional time away from their families and their already loaded schedules. Furthermore, many said they wanted to go beyond merely raising difficult questions to actually taking action on issues that they found personally meaningful.”

The first novels in this book club series chosen by the WBP for this program include the following:

My Sister’s Keeper by Jodi Picoult, which explores the impact of embryo selection and “designer babies” on one family and the heart-wrenching choices that ensue.

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro goes a step further, examining human cloning and organ donation from the perspective of an isolated community of human clones.

Oryx & Crake by Margaret Atwood presents a world so altered by the effects of genetic engineering that both society and the natural environment are profoundly affected.

When read in this order, the selected novels take readers along a continuum from technologically feasible issues surrounding organ transplants and genetic engineering to futuristic scenarios involving advanced applications of these and other biotechnologies that force us to examine many of the implications of what it means to be human.
Public Policy Implications of Bioethical Issues

Beyond the literary analysis and examination of important bioethical issues, another important aspect of the WBP book club program is that it ties the issues raised in these three books to current public policy debates. The book club materials provide women with guidance on how to get involved, share their thoughts with their legislators and help shape legislation.
The most pressing public policy issue the WBP would like to see women take a closer look at after reading these books is human germline genetic modification, which is sometimes referred to as producing “designer babies.” The WBP believes the application of genetic engineering in this area will have profound implications for women and their families. Whether they feel limits should be placed on this technology or believe it should be banned outright, this book club forum offers women a unique opportunity to discuss these issues with one another and explore their feelings about genetic engineering and other biomedical advances on both a personal and policy level.
“We hope that women will come away from this experience feeling informed and motivated to get involved,” said Hinsch. “Although we have included three novels in our campaign, Jodi Picoult’s book My Sister’s Keeper was really our original inspiration. The way she captures the real-life ethical issues around ‘designer babies’ from the perspective of one family really demonstrates the power literature has to let us explore unfamiliar situations and reach our own conclusions.”
Jodi Picoult, author of 12 other novels in addition to My Sister’s Keeper, including the recently published The Tenth Circle, shares this goal. “I was honored when Kathryn asked me to participate in this book club campaign,” Picoult said. “I truly believe the time to address the impact of these emerging technologies is now, and I think this program offers an accessible and relevant way for women to begin engaging with others on these issues. I’m pleased that my novels can play a small
part in that effort.”

All book club program materials are available on our Web site.

Monday, April 10, 2006

Honey, We're Killing the Kids!

No, it's not a sequel to the kids movie, Honey I Shrunk the Kids! -- it's the title of The Learning Channel's latest series to focus on the American diet and the impact on our health care costs and our children -- Last week's issue of the medical journal Pediatrics found that American children are increasingly too big to fit into standard child safety car seats. According to the American Obesity Association, "the percentage of children and adolescents who are overweight and obese is now higher than ever before."

Friday, April 07, 2006

Cultural alibis, dubious beliefs



Because my culture says it’s ok seems to be the new catch phrase for behaviors all along the questionable behaviors continuum.

For instance, one of the lessons that has emerged from the ongoing rape trial of our ex-Deputy President, Jacob Zuma, is that If you don’t have sex with a woman (and they are wearing a skirt, so clearly wanting it), you are morally wrong and criminally accountable. Heck, you may even be charged with rape. His culture has taught him that leaving a woman in that state (of sexual arousal) was “the worst thing a man could do.” Funny that, I thought rape might have claimed that title. But then, I’m just a woman. And an outsider to the norms dictated by Zuma’s culture.

It seems that culture gives you an alibi for just about anything you feel like doing. In a recent survey of school boys in our KwaZulu-Natal province, beating girls and forcing them to have sex was all justifiable in cultural terms. While one boy said that beating a girl was acceptable practice to keep her in line, another said that hitting a girl meant that you loved her, because if you didn’t (love her), you wouldn’t bother (to hit her). Following this line of argument into marriage, most of the participants believed that forced sex within a marriage was not a problem: “When we are married, I can force you to have sex with me because I know that I pay my money to buy you…” Nor did the youngsters think it was a problem for a man to have sex whenever and with whomever he wanted, even if it was not with his wife.

And what about the risk of AIDS? Well, one can hardly blame young boys for being unconcerned about the possibility of contracting the virus if our former Deputy President, a man who continues to command a strong following and who, ironically, is the former head of the National AIDS Council, has openly admitted to engaging in unprotected sex with an HIV-positive woman. If boys – and girls – want to have unsafe sex, all they need to do is shower afterwards. During his trial, Zuma has testified that he showered after having consensual sex with the alleged rape victim to minimize his risk of contracting HIV from her. A revelation that is sure to set a good example for those who ardently follow and admire their leader: if you have unprotected sex with someone who is HIV-positive, you will be ok so long as you take an anti-HIV shower afterwards, wash all that yucky virus off of you.